Why I&S Grades Often Feel Inconsistent
One of the most common complaints about MYP Individuals & Societies is this:
“I included lots of facts — so why didn’t I score higher?”
In the IB Middle Years Programme, Individuals & Societies is not marked on how much information students include. It is marked on how well students use knowledge to explain, analyse, and argue.
Once the assessment criteria are understood, grades become far more predictable.
The Big Picture: What the Criteria Are Designed to Test
MYP Individuals & Societies uses four assessment criteria, each targeting a different academic skill:
- Criterion A: Knowing and understanding
- Criterion B: Investigating
- Criterion C: Communicating
- Criterion D: Thinking critically
Most tasks assess one or two criteria only. Trying to address all four in every task often weakens responses.
Criterion A: Knowing and Understanding
What it assesses:
- Knowledge of concepts, facts, and terminology
- Understanding of key ideas within the subject
- Ability to use knowledge appropriately
What high-level responses look like
- Accurate, relevant knowledge
- Case studies used selectively
- Concepts explained, not just named
Common mistake:
Listing facts or case studies without linking them to the question.
Knowledge only earns marks when it is .
